cvprofiles · construct-validity profile

Trust — cells demeaned + LLM

Admissible measurement set under a stated nomological network, and the image of β on that set. Empty sets and wide ranges are scientific features.

Construct-identified range

[L, U] · method = min/max B*

[-0.317486, -0.317486]

Width = 0.000000 · point-ID · bootstrap percentile band = [-0.394007, -0.199811]

Target β = corr_y on outcome gps_trust_cell. Range uses only measures in M*; rejected β values are shown below but never enter [L,U].

Run freeze

run_id9461b368443ff5ad950c9b466d2ccc178b14655997f1408e2b0f8f88f59a9a77
package3.0.2
scores_hashff11b172db7ec3ea13d700b6abad6724c7ad68ecb27585a1caf542397f92499b
network_hashd0afa9002b03c34746a448be1fbb9affc2c0ca99f9b3f2dd5956160912e218d0
beta_hash19fe88c41c4644897cee8c770b625bd57adbae206e1efc2774599c116eacd51e
δ0.0
seed20260814
networktrust_cells_llm_extension

Bootstrap inference · additive to headline range

Units-only Efron resampling; percentile band over non-empty replicates. The headline [L, U] above remains min/max β(M*) on the full sample.

replicates1000
seed20260814
quantiles[0.025, 0.975]
non-empty1000
empty0 (0.000)
degenerate0 (0.000)
band[-0.394007, -0.199811]

Uncertainty band · additive to headline range

Per-side α/2 quantiles over non-empty bootstrap replicates (α = 0.1). Heuristic band — not a confidence interval, not a holdout-robustness band. The headline [L, U] above remains min/max β(M*) on the full sample.

α0.1
κ2.0
quantiles[0.05, 0.95]
band[-0.382417, -0.239745]
empty rate0.000
degenerate rate0.000

Boundary attribution · |margin| ≤ κ·SE

measuremarginSEboundary
m_trust_general -0.176854 0.049025 no
m_trust_in_group -0.268407 0.043041 no
m_trust_out_group -0.274989 0.051229 no
m_trust_institution -0.627369 0.039714 no
m_trust_composite -0.473703 0.045587 no
m_llm_trust_llama -0.077267 0.040003 yes
m_llm_trust_phi 0.132638 0.043311 no
m_noise -0.171912 0.048268 no

Admission frequency p̂m

measurep̂m
m_trust_general 0.000
m_trust_in_group 0.000
m_trust_out_group 0.000
m_trust_institution 0.000
m_trust_composite 0.000
m_llm_trust_llama 0.022
m_llm_trust_phi 1.000
m_noise 0.000

Heuristic uncertainty band over non-empty bootstrap replicates (selection uncertainty on the pooled sample; holdout verdict is a full-sample point finding outside the band). Not a confidence interval; not a holdout-robustness band. Boundary attribution: |margin_m| <= kappa * SE_m.

θ-grid sensitivity · diagnostic viewport

λ scales threshold magnitudes only. λ is never auto-selected; the headline is always λ=1.0. This grid is not part of the freeze preimage.

λ|M*|emptyLU
0.5 2 no -0.317486 0.179299
1.0 1 no -0.317486 -0.317486
1.5 1 no -0.317486 -0.317486
2.0 0 yes — —

θ-anchors · pre-data audit

One pre-data anchor per restriction (hash 07533ac8ce87…). The engine enforces completeness + hash; "pre-data" is a process commitment, not a temporal claim.

restrictionkindpre-dataanchor
conv_edu_cell literature yes falk2018_table_v — Same education implication applied within country (cell means). θ=0.20.
mono_edu_cell literature yes falk2018_table_v — Leftover within-country rank-monotone education restriction. θ=0.15.

Menu admission

M* size = 1 / 8. Slack rule: admit if sr(m) ≥ −δ for all r.

measure status β(m) failed restrictions
m_trust_general rejected 0.052428 conv_edu_cell
m_trust_in_group rejected 0.223931 conv_edu_cell
m_trust_out_group rejected 0.211423 conv_edu_cell
m_trust_institution rejected 0.284723 conv_edu_cell
m_trust_composite rejected 0.317611 conv_edu_cell
m_llm_trust_llama rejected 0.179299 conv_edu_cell
m_llm_trust_phi admissible -0.317486 —
m_noise rejected 0.014662 conv_edu_cell

Slack matrix sr(m)

Positive / zero ≈ satisfied at δ=0.0. Negative = violation magnitude.

measure conv_edu_cell mono_edu_cell
m_trust_general -0.176854 -0.131341
m_trust_in_group -0.268407 -0.233353
m_trust_out_group -0.274989 -0.224794
m_trust_institution -0.627369 -0.552204
m_trust_composite -0.473703 -0.414333
m_llm_trust_llama -0.077267 -0.065537
m_llm_trust_phi 0.148808 0.132638
m_noise -0.171912 -0.119007

Network (researcher-owned)

Engine does not invent restrictions. Agent may author oracle R for synthetic DGPs only.