EFFECTIVE_MODEL: [ provider/model: minimax/MiniMax-M3.1-Flash (mcode CLI v0.7.4, binary
  /Users/corvette/.minimax-code/bin/mcode); settings: effort xhigh, launch argv
  ["/Users/corvette/.minimax-code/bin/mcode","--model","minimax/MiniMax-M3.1-Flash"],
  Herdr terminal t7j (name u8-mcode-r1, parent t75), cwd
  "/Users/corvette/Documents/Projects Coding/Skill Lens"; runtimeMode: interactive
  agent TUI (not one-shot print mode), coordinator-owned readable/steerable terminal;
  interactionMode: interactive, single task turn, durable file report + hc send to
  t75 | evidence: REQUESTED roster "mcode CLI / MiniMax-M3.1-Flash / xhigh effort"
  (mcode-brief.txt line 2) vs CONFIGURED argv confirmed via `hc get t7j --json`
  (model prefix resolved by the coordinator after t7g was rejected for a bare model
  id) vs CONFIRMED model and effort at report time: `hc get t7j` reports
  state=live/status=working and the mcode status bar reads
  "M3.1-Flash · Effort xhigh". Effort was observed as "max" early in the review and
  as "xhigh" at report time (changed by the coordinator mid-review; the earlier
  `hc send u8-mcode-r1 "/model"` was delivered as a chat prompt, not a TUI command).
  No unverified element remains in the roster. ]

VERDICT:         pass

  Reviewer 1 (standards/specification axis). No blocker found. The U8 change is
  inside the frozen plan's allowed scope, keeps every read-only/captured-data
  guarantee, leaves CLI JSON, snapshots, goldens, the controller and the public
  models untouched, and its documentation agrees with the tested behaviour. Two
  non-blocking documentation-accuracy items are listed below; both are text-only
  and are the coordinator's to action before the commit. Two suspected problems
  were withdrawn after verification (see CONCEDED).

BLOCKERS:        [ none ]

  No defect on this axis. Specifically checked and found sound:

  - Frozen contract. `git show b5947840:docs/plans/2026-11-04-tui-u8-polish-help-docs.md
    | shasum -a 256` = 01f6f250be358ed2168170e06513c1908ef616208a204d8f50f9dfa03f0c26de,
    exactly the briefed plan hash. HEAD = a9d67b808ce235a543e63fba40b478da2a96c3e3 as
    briefed. `git diff b5947840 HEAD` touches that plan file by one line only (the
    `Reference:` line), which the frozen plan itself anticipates ("the reference-only
    follow-up changes this line only"). The operative contract is intact.
  - Allowed scope. The patch changes 14 tracked files and adds 2 (skill_lens/tui/help.py,
    tests/test_tui_help.py) — all inside the plan's "Allowed future implementation files"
    table. I compared every one of the 1,815 tracked files at a9d67b8 against a tree
    built from `git archive a9d67b8` + the supplied patch: exactly those 14 differ.
    Unchanged: skill_lens/core/ (controller state machine, snapshot capture),
    skill_lens/models/, skill_lens/registry/, skill_lens/cli.py, skill_lens/render.py,
    skill_lens/presentation/, skill_lens/tui/session.py, skill_lens/tui/json_view.py,
    tests/fixtures/ (all snapshots and goldens), pyproject.toml, uv.lock,
    .github/workflows/ci.yml, AGENTS.md, docs/process/, docs/archive/, docs/plans/.
    Nothing in the plan's exclusion list was touched; no scope amendment was needed.
  - Patch fidelity (the reviewed artifact is the real change). I applied
    u8-product.patch to a pristine `git archive a9d67b8` tree outside the checkout and
    compared SHA-256 for all 16 files: byte-identical to the live working tree. The
    patch is complete and uncurated — git status shows no other product/test/doc change.
  - Read-only, captured-data, optional and offline. skill_lens/tui/help.py imports only
    textual widgets plus SessionController for read-only status; no Rich, no CLI renderer,
    no filesystem/process/network call, no log file (plan §2). `grep` finds no
    socket/requests/urllib/http/subprocess/shutil/os import anywhere under skill_lens/tui/.
    The recursive AST guard (tests/test_tui_read_only.py:345 check_source_tree) rglobs the
    whole tui package, so the new module is included, and the package-discovery test now
    asserts help.py (tests/test_tui_read_only.py:374-380). Mutation cases 11 and 12 prove
    the guard actually fires on a banned import and on a Path write inside help.py.
  - JSON compatibility. json_view.py, the CLI and the renderers are untouched, so the CLI
    JSON shape cannot have changed. New test
    tests/test_tui_help.py:2152 compares all six TUI JSON documents byte-for-byte with
    `runner.invoke(cli_app, [..., "--json"])` stdout on identical inputs; the pre-existing
    per-screen oracle tests in tests/test_tui_json.py, test_tui_agents.py, test_tui_compare.py
    and test_tui_doctor.py are retained. `git diff HEAD -- tests/fixtures/` is empty, so no
    snapshot or golden was regenerated.
  - Keyboard contract (spot-checked against plan §1-§8). App bindings at
    skill_lens/tui/app.py:129-133 give a non-priority `question_mark` and an app-level
    priority `f1`; HelpScreen bindings at skill_lens/tui/help.py:204-211 contain no competing
    `f1`, so the app priority key is not preempted. Dismiss keys route through
    app.close_help, which returns unless `self.screen is expected`
    (skill_lens/tui/app.py:255-257) — only the exact instance can close itself. Repeated
    opens cannot stack (app.py:234-236 returns when the current screen is a HelpScreen).
    Help IDs are unique help-* (help-frame/help-title/help-body/help-content/help-session/
    help-close). Layered Back is explained in the Compare context rows, not merely implied.
  - Documentation accuracy. README has no relative and no same-page link (the DEVELOPMENT
    absolute-URL rule); I independently resolved all 46 relative link targets across the
    five edited documents and every one exists. Exit-code claims match the code:
    bare launch without the extra prints help plus a tip and exits 0
    (skill_lens/cli.py:163-166); explicit `skill-lens tui` without the extra exits
    ExitCode.USAGE = 2 (cli.py:279-287) and a non-interactive stream also exits 2
    (cli.py:288-295); normal quit 0 and accepted internal fault 3. The documented capture
    budget matches DEFAULT_MAX_SNAPSHOT_BYTES = 256 * 1024 * 1024
    (skill_lens/core/snapshot.py:67) with 0 disabling it (cli.py:263). The specification's
    Phase 7 heading was corrected from "planned, not built" to "implemented in development
    through U8" while keeping "Published PyPI 0.1.1 contains no TUI", which is exactly the
    published-vs-development distinction the plan required. CHANGELOG records U8 only under
    Unreleased → Added, makes no 0.2 release claim, and preserves published headings.
  - Acceptance evidence. All 12 mutation cases in
    docs/validation/u8/implementation/mutations/results.json show a passing control before
    (exit 0), a meaningful mutant failure (exit 1) and a passing restored control (exit 0),
    with syntax_or_import_error false and no timeout anywhere — the A8 standard, not exit
    code alone. I read the mutant logs directly: 11 and 12 fail on the real assertion
    ("Shipped tui/ code contains prohibited operations: help.py:34: Banned import
    'subprocess'"), 08 fails on a real document inequality. The acceptance matrix maps
    A1-A10 to named tests, A7 maps each empty/error state to a concrete test, and A9/A10
    point at gates.json and the four final-*.log files. The implementer's changed-files.txt
    lists exactly the 16 changed product/test/doc files and correctly omits the unattributed
    artifacts. Coordinator verification.json records the four gates (1338 passed, 1 skipped,
    90.12%, mypy over 46 files, ruff check and format clean), the native terminal smoke
    result, and an explicit claim boundary that excludes human visual approval, the
    Linux/Python matrix, hosted CI and built-wheel qualification.

SUGGESTIONS:     [ non-blocking ]

  1. Stale verification-status sentence at commit time.
     Location: README.md:228, DEVELOPMENT.md:85, FULL_SCREEN_TUI.md:19, FULL_SCREEN_TUI.md:494
     and CHANGELOG.md:130 all say "Coordinator verification and independent review remain
     separate". Problem: the sentence was accurate when written, but
     docs/validation/u8/coordinator/verification.json now exists in the same working tree
     and records coordinator technical verification as passed, and the plan allows and A10
     expects docs/validation/u8/ to carry the execution receipt and the final-review
     decisions. If that evidence is committed together with these documents, the shipped
     commit states "coordinator verification ... remain[s] separate" while containing the
     coordinator verification record. Expected behaviour: the current-status statements match
     the evidence shipped in the same commit. Evidence: `git status` shows
     "?? docs/validation/u8/coordinator/" untracked and ready to be committed;
     docs/validation/u8/coordinator/verification.json has "acceptance":
     {"coordinator_technical_verification": "passed", "independent_final_review": "pending
     user-named roster or an explicit user waiver"}. Remedy: when the coordinator commits,
     either point these sentences at the coordinator record and state that independent review
     is the remaining step, or state the actual state. If the product is committed first and
     the evidence separately, no edit is needed. Nothing else in the wording is wrong.

  2. The delivered keymap table omits F1.
     Location: FULL_SCREEN_TUI.md §8.2 "Keymap (draft)" table, lines 445-463 — the table
     lists `?` → Help overlay (line 462) and `q` / `Ctrl-C` → Quit (line 463) but has no
     `F1` row. Problem: plan §1 requires the new additive key to be "documented everywhere",
     and the documentation bullet for the TUI design asks to reconcile "actual contextual
     keys". F1 is described in the prose immediately below the table
     (FULL_SCREEN_TUI.md:483) and in README.md:165, README.md:221,
     SKILL_LENS_SPECIFICATION.md:392 and CHANGELOG.md:117, so the document is not wrong about
     the key existing — but a reader of the keymap table itself would conclude F1 does not
     exist, and the table already lists other app-level keys. Expected behaviour: the
     keymap table lists every delivered key, including the priority F1 toggle that works
     while typing. Evidence: the table is the canonical key list and omits the key;
     skill_lens/tui/app.py:132 binds F1 as an app-level priority toggle. Remedy: add one
     row after line 462, e.g. "| `F1` | Toggle Help (works even while typing) |".
     DEVELOPMENT.md contains no keymap by design, so it needs no change.

FILES_AT_RISK:   [

  - README.md:228, DEVELOPMENT.md:85, FULL_SCREEN_TUI.md:19, FULL_SCREEN_TUI.md:494,
    CHANGELOG.md:130 — the verification-status sentence (SUGGESTION 1). Text-only.
  - FULL_SCREEN_TUI.md:445-463 — the §8.2 keymap table missing the F1 row
    (SUGGESTION 2). Text-only.
  - Reviewed and found compliant, no action: skill_lens/tui/help.py, skill_lens/tui/app.py,
    skill_lens/tui/home.py, skill_lens/tui/why.py, skill_lens/tui/diff.py,
    skill_lens/tui/agents.py, skill_lens/tui/compare.py, skill_lens/tui/doctor.py,
    tests/test_tui_help.py, tests/test_tui_read_only.py, tests/test_tui_home.py,
    README.md, DEVELOPMENT.md, CHANGELOG.md, SKILL_LENS_SPECIFICATION.md, FULL_SCREEN_TUI.md.

CONCEDED:        [ points withdrawn after argument ]

  1. "Plan SHA-256 mismatch — the frozen plan was edited after the freeze." Withdrawn.
     The hash of the plan at the briefed operative commit b5947840 is exactly
     01f6f250be358ed2168170e06513c1908ef616208a204d8f50f9dfa03f0c26de, and the working
     tree copy hashes to 63f22879db2bd44237801455d0dc739b90087db27d695e5662763027e2deca66.
     The difference is the single `Reference:` line changed by the briefed reference-only
     follow-up commit a9d67b8, which the frozen plan's own text authorises. No contract
     breach.
  2. "The brief undercounts the unattributed artifacts (seven four-byte files, not eight)."
     Withdrawn. before.json contains exactly eight entries with the blat hash: 3y5luqdv,
     xa1fl79v, _6r0sqne, m5txb5iu, rbvraqtn, skl6wira, y7vpe7r2 and
     docs/validation/u8/implementation/mutations/7pma619t. The count of eight is correct;
     the separate empty file .path is separate again. I deleted nothing.
  3. "The supplied patch may be a curated subset of the real change." Withdrawn. Applying
     the patch to a pristine a9d67b8 tree reproduces all 16 files byte-for-byte, and the
     working tree contains no other product/test/doc modification.

APPENDIX — VERIFICATION EVIDENCE (supporting the fields above)

  Method. Read-only throughout: AGENTS.md, the frozen plan at b5947840, the complete
  patch, all 16 changed sources and tests, and the whole docs/validation/u8/ record. I
  applied the patch and compared hashes in a throwaway tree under /tmp only; no file in
  the repository was created, edited, moved, deleted or renamed, no formatter, linter,
  installer, git commit/checkout/stash or snapshot regeneration was run, and no test
  suite was executed. I relied on the recorded gate and mutation logs rather than
  re-running them, and I did not infer correctness from pass counts.

  Commands used (all read-only): git rev-parse/log/diff/status/ls-tree/show/archive,
  shasum, grep, and file reads. `git archive` was written to /tmp/u8-patch-check only.

  Local reproduction of the boundary checks:
    git show b5947840:docs/plans/2026-11-04-tui-u8-polish-help-docs.md | shasum -a 256
      -> 01f6f250be358ed2168170e06513c1908ef616208a204d8f50f9dfa03f0c26de  (matches brief)
    git rev-parse HEAD
      -> a9d67b808ce235a543e63fba40b478da2a96c3e3  (matches brief)
    git diff b5947840 HEAD --stat
      -> docs/plans/2026-11-04-tui-u8-polish-help-docs.md | 2 +-  (Reference: line only)
    git archive a9d67b8 | tar -x -C /tmp/u8-patch-check && git apply u8-product.patch
      -> applies cleanly; all 16 files byte-identical to the working tree
    per-file SHA-256 comparison of all 1,815 tracked files at a9d67b8 vs the patched tree
      -> exactly 14 differ, all inside the plan's allowed table
    git diff HEAD -- tests/fixtures/
      -> empty (no snapshot or golden changed)

  Known limitations carried forward unchanged and not treated as findings: local
  macOS / Python 3.11.16 / Textual 8.2.8 checks only; no human visual approval, no
  Linux or Python matrix, no hosted CI, no built-wheel qualification; cooperative quit
  cannot forcibly stop a running thread; Help's static body captures focus and mode at
  open while the live session section keeps updating; eight unattributed four-byte
  blat artifacts remain, were not touched and must not be deleted.

  Boundary note: reviewer 2 covers behavioural lifecycle and test gaps. I did not
  duplicate that axis, except where a lifecycle decision also bears on a standards
  rule — the exact-instance dismissal guard, the no-stacking guard, the app-level
  priority F1 with no competing modal binding, the read-only AST guard reaching the new
  module, and the CLI-serializer JSON equality test. I did not attempt to re-litigate
  reviewer 2's findings.
