READ-ONLY CRITIC TASK. You are reviewing, not implementing.

Do NOT create, edit, move, delete or rename any file in the repository. Do NOT run
any command that writes: no formatters, no linters with --fix, no install, no
git commit/checkout/stash, no snapshot or golden regeneration, no test runs that
write into the checkout. Test output, if you need it, goes only to a temporary
directory outside the repository.

If you believe a change is required, do not make it. Report it instead.

Return only the report format below. Nothing else.

# Fresh targeted final-review follow-up — U5, round 2
You are a fresh independent critic in /Users/corvette/Documents/Projects Coding/Skill Lens. The owner selected MiniMax M3.1 Flash/max through MCode and GLM-5.3/max through Qoder for this mission, including targeted follow-ups. Do not delegate, run tests/gates/runtime checks, write reports/files, launch workers or restart planning. Return the report in your final response only.

# Exact contract and state
Frozen plan: docs/plans/2026-10-29-tui-u5-diff-json.md @ 69a477ba9054a21030d038ed98a62962a1862d88.
HEAD / implementation diff base: fb85ddb91ef518ed86b7af84ffb0e87ae69f4afd. Product changes remain uncommitted.
Current complete tracked/untracked manifest fingerprint: cf1584f34c43be32695c8baee96d1c473d97fc37686098ae9156dae35502fe50 (2428 paths), at /private/var/folders/tf/jsdyxcts6y72fs98s7wl3dfm0000gn/T/skill-lens-u5-final-followup-retry-o54c1jmd/before-manifest.json. Status: before-status.txt beside it.
Verified correction-only patch against the exact first-final-review bytes: /private/var/folders/tf/jsdyxcts6y72fs98s7wl3dfm0000gn/T/skill-lens-u5-final-followup-retry-o54c1jmd/correction.patch. The coordinator reconstructed the old versions from the recorded round-1 patch and verified their SHA-256 against the old manifest before generating this focused diff.
ONLY changed Python files since that full council: skill_lens/tui/why.py; tests/test_tui_diff.py; tests/test_tui_json.py. Implementation-record appendix also changed; no other product code changed. Unchanged positive full-review/mutation scope remains valid. This is not a third broad review or a repeat of the entire spec audit.

# Required reading
- docs/validation/u5/final-review/round1/disposition.md: the original blocker, four-case coordinator reproduction, accepted FR2 suggestion and explicit rejected/deferred items.
- Both original final reports in that same directory. MiniMax found FR1; GLM passed but its claim that the topmost guard prevented double resume was contradicted by the coordinator's observed defect. Do not treat either verdict as proof or a vote; verify the corrected mechanism.
- The focused correction patch, current affected functions/tests, and relevant source dependencies: tui/app.py close_diff, Why suspend/resume/rebuild/request paths, Textual lifecycle/focus semantics as needed; json_view.py/Home snapshot-refusal path for FR2. Read the corresponding frozen plan navigation/lifecycle/JSON clauses. Do not flood context with the old full patch or unrelated repo history.
- /private/var/folders/tf/jsdyxcts6y72fs98s7wl3dfm0000gn/T/skill-lens-u5-final-followup-retry-o54c1jmd/correction-evidence.json: complete final gate outputs, red/green summaries and coordinator's original four-case after-fix smoke. The original full before-fix log was lost with OS temporary files; its inspected 8/8 focus failures and green evidence are retained in this recovered JSON and the permanent implementer appendix.
- docs/validation/u5/implementation-record.md final correction appendix (implementer report, not acceptance).

# What to decide
FR1 product fix: _restore_detail_focus now retains the remembered widget while can_focus/is_mounted/display remain valid, instead of clearing it after the first restore; _rebuild_from_snapshot clears the old reference on generation replacement. App's explicit resume and Textual ScreenResume both remain. Does this actually make focus restoration idempotent without stale-widget resurrection, wrong focus fallback, changed expansion/scroll/agent state, duplicate requests, cancelled newer ownership or broken covered-refresh/removal behavior?
FR1 tests: 8 parameter rows (candidate-title/body x 100x30/60x24 x Esc/Backspace), two actual push/pop trips per row, real Tab navigation, actual focus identity after lifecycle/deferred work, retained ordinary state and worker count. A companion covered-refresh test verifies stale focus is dropped and a valid ordinary target receives focus. Ensure assertions discriminate the real original bug, not mock echoes or source text. Lifecycle counters establish exercised ordering but do not replace behavioral focus assertions.
FR2: tiny positive capture budget refuses the initial capture. Home J must display a meaningful refusal with document=None, no fabricated ScanReport or false loading, no sticky unexpected fault and normal quit. Confirm the test reaches the real refused state and observes the actual screen, with safe synthetic HOME; no new product semantics were added for this test.

# Evidence and limits
Final implementer gates, inspected by coordinator: 1192 passed, 1 existing case-sensitive-filesystem skip; 90.15% combined coverage with branch measurement; mypy clean over 41 product files; Ruff lint/format clean. Logs retained in correction-evidence.json. Eight focus regressions failed before the fix at the originating-widget identity assertion and passed afterward. Coordinator separately reran the original real-key smoke: candidate/body focus at both terminal sizes is now preserved in all four cases (exit 0); the original same smoke failed all four before. No coordinator product/test edits.
Previous unchanged full council and mutation evidence: docs/validation/u5/coordinator-verification.md and mutations/round1.json, round2.json. Do not rerun gates or the entire campaign. No physical-terminal or human visual approval is claimed for the implementer's latest headless checks; coordinator has real terminal smoke from the previous product tree and will exercise the corrected path separately. Source evidence is not proof of upstream model identity.

# Boundaries
High-risk review policy and exact guard apply. No unrelated audit, speculative framework/counter/state-summary redesign, cosmetic removal-notice change, dead-quit cleanup or export-inventory test reinstatement. These were explicitly adjudicated as outside this correction. A concrete newly introduced in-scope blocker can still be reported with source/contract evidence. Do not require incidental wording, wiring, mock-forwarding or source-text assertions. Preserve .path and the unrelated native-asyncio/2026-10-25 work; never inspect real installed skills, credentials, global configs or unrelated sessions.
The coordinator owns before/after full-tree fingerprints; you need not re-hash unrelated historical artifacts. Plan/read-only instructions are not an OS sandbox guarantee.

# Identity and required report
Same advertised MiniMax/GLM families as owner-approved round 1; no advertised overlap with the OpenAI coordinator or owner-identified DeepSeek implementer. Upstream serving identity unverified. This session explicitly requests max effort; do not confuse it with historical planning xhigh. State only visible configured evidence, then stop identity research. The coordinator checks exact-run runtime receipts separately.

Return:
EFFECTIVE_MODEL: requested/configured model, effort, modes, evidence and upstream limits.
VERDICT: pass | changes_required | unverified.
BLOCKERS: none, or numbered severity/file:line/actual-vs-expected/contract/evidence/smallest correction. A missing gate is not a product defect; distinguish evidence limits.
SUGGESTIONS: non-blocking and within the correction scope, or none.
FILES_AT_RISK: affected consumers/files, or none.
CONCEDED: FR1/FR2 disposition and prior concerns ruled out, checks not run and evidence limits.
Concise, evidence-backed, no patches or file writes. If FR1/FR2 are resolved and no concrete new blocker exists, say pass. Do not invent busywork to produce findings.


# Interrupted attempt recovery
The 2026-10-31 targeted attempts stopped mid-tool-call with NO final verdict. Both old process IDs are absent and the GLM pane is gone; the old MiniMax pane is now the coordinator pane and is never to be touched. This is a fresh retry of the same targeted follow-up, NOT a third broad wave. Full checkout fingerprint still exactly matches the original 2428-entry pre-wave fingerprint. Supplied gate evidence was recovered losslessly from the Qoder transcript read result, not recreated or fabricated. Some original temporary log/probe paths no longer exist. Do not rerun them or treat missing cleaned scratch files as product defects.

Your requested route: minimax/MiniMax-M3.1-Flash, max, MCode
