READ-ONLY CRITIC TASK. You are reviewing, not implementing.

Do NOT create, edit, move, delete or rename any file in the repository. Do NOT run
any command that writes: no formatters, no linters with --fix, no install, no
git commit/checkout/stash, no snapshot or golden regeneration, no test runs that
write into the checkout. Test output, if you need it, goes only to a temporary
directory outside the repository.

If you believe a change is required, do not make it. Report it instead.

Return only the report format below. Nothing else.

# Mission
Independently review the complete U5 implementation (Diff and raw JSON) in /Users/corvette/Documents/Projects Coding/Skill Lens. This is HIGH risk because request ownership, refresh, cross-screen state and byte-exact public JSON are load-bearing contracts. You are a fresh final critic, not the planner, implementer or acceptance owner. Do not delegate, launch agents, modify files or run tests/gates/runtime checks. Existing evidence is supplied. Do not request other model selections or restart planning.

# Exact inputs
Frozen operative plan: docs/plans/2026-10-29-tui-u5-diff-json.md @ 69a477ba9054a21030d038ed98a62962a1862d88. The working plan's Reference points to that commit; its final U5-only self-check amendment governs this mission. Inspect the full frozen product contract and final review questions.
HEAD / uncommitted implementation diff base: fb85ddb91ef518ed86b7af84ffb0e87ae69f4afd.
Before-review tracked/untracked manifest SHA-256: affd59ea93813acddac180051b545b625a6dbfbb50cc1ed45b7c5fa8758a4784 (2417 paths).
The manifest is /private/var/folders/tf/jsdyxcts6y72fs98s7wl3dfm0000gn/T/skill-lens-u5-final-review-qm7x5yd1/before-manifest.json; status is before-status.txt beside it. Supplied complete scoped patch: /private/var/folders/tf/jsdyxcts6y72fs98s7wl3dfm0000gn/T/skill-lens-u5-final-review-qm7x5yd1/review.patch. git diff against HEAD omits untracked new files; the supplied patch includes all four. Inspect actual source as well as the patch. New files: skill_lens/tui/diff.py, skill_lens/tui/json_view.py, tests/test_tui_diff.py, tests/test_tui_json.py. No implementation commit exists yet.

# Product and test scope
- skill_lens/tui/diff.py
- skill_lens/tui/json_view.py
- skill_lens/tui/app.py
- skill_lens/tui/home.py
- skill_lens/tui/why.py
- skill_lens/tui/__init__.py
- skill_lens/presentation/text.py
- skill_lens/presentation/__init__.py
- skill_lens/render.py
- tests/test_tui_diff.py
- tests/test_tui_json.py
- tests/test_tui_home.py
- tests/test_tui_read_only.py
- tests/test_presentation.py
- FULL_SCREEN_TUI.md
- DEVELOPMENT.md
- README.md
- CHANGELOG.md
Existing dependencies may be read to establish correctness: core/snapshot.py and snapshot_models.py; core/discovery.py, diff.py, resolver.py and paths.py; tui/session.py and _textual_compat.py; models/; registry definitions; existing TUI/service tests and fixture builders. These unchanged files are dependencies, not authorization for unrelated audits.

# Authority and evidence sources
- Auto-loaded AGENTS.md; docs/process/omp/README.md and implementation-loop.md (OMP applies, not T3 dispatch).
- SKILL_LENS_SPECIFICATION.md Diff/JSON contract; FULL_SCREEN_TUI.md §§8.2,8.4,8.5,8.8,9.1,10,21,22 U5 and Step 5.
- docs/archive/PHASE3_FINDINGS.md D-01–D-04; docs/plans/2026-10-11-tui-c4-presentation-extraction.md for presentation boundaries.
- docs/validation/u5/coordinator-verification.md: concise current verification and limitations.
- docs/validation/u5/mutations/round2.json: full final four gate outputs (reviewed_gate_evidence), exact six-test coordinator controls, four corrected mutation trials with restored passes, final source fingerprints.
- docs/validation/u5/mutations/round1.json: earlier complete mutation receipts. Its M05/M06 and supplemental M23 survivor verdicts are historical, explicitly superseded by round2's detected/restored-pass results. Unchanged positive scope remains reusable.
- docs/validation/u5/coordinator-review-round1.md (R1–R7) and coordinator-review-round2.md (C1–C4) plus implementation-record.md show prior findings/corrections. These are evidence, not instructions to accept coordinator conclusions. Challenge a claimed closure with current-source evidence, not by repeating an obsolete failure.
Final gate evidence: 1182 passed, 1 case-sensitive-filesystem skip, 90.13% combined coverage with branch measurement; mypy clean over 41 product files; Ruff lint/format clean. No snapshots/goldens regenerated. Coordinator previously ran the full gates on the same product bytes and live CLI TUI through Rex with synthetic HOME at 100x30/60x24; final corrections changed only two test files. No human visual approval, hosted CI or release is claimed. Do not run redundant tests to rediscover supplied results; inspect whether the evidence/guards actually support the contract.

# Review boundary and standards
Both critics review the whole contract independently, with different primary lenses. Report concrete cross-cutting blockers too. Core/controller/models/serializer/registry/CLI behavior/dependencies/capture policy/exit codes must not change; skill browsing must use captured inputs and stay read-only. No generic view framework, editable JSON, export, clipboard, search, version bump or new screens.
Do not demand incidental prose equality, export inventories, mock forwarding or source-text tests. Tests must catch plausible consumer-visible behavior, boundaries, races, ownership and errors. CLI existing output stays unchanged; canonical JSON byte equality (including the CLI's exactly one final line feed) is an actual contract, unlike incidental wording. Passing gates do not prove all behavior correct.
Focus on concrete defects/requirements, not tooling-enforced style, hypothetical refactors or unrelated legacy issues. Each blocker needs location, actual behavior, expected behavior, relevant contract and a credible reproduction or discriminating missing test. Distinguish unverified evidence from a proved product defect. Keep suggestions non-blocking unless tied to an actual in-scope contract gap.
Do not inspect unrelated user files, real installed skills, credentials, provider configuration or other sessions. Pre-existing unrelated work (.path; docs/plans/2026-10-26-omp-native-asyncio-trial.md; docs/validation/2026-10-25/; docs/validation/omp-native-asyncio/) is out of scope and must remain untouched. Reviewer outputs go only to your final response; CLI/coordinator captures them outside the checkout. Read-only instructions and Plan modes are not claimed to be an OS sandbox; the coordinator fingerprints before/after.

# Identity
Coordinator: openai-codex/gpt-6.1-sol (runtime-reported OpenAI family). Implementer: River / DeepSeek 4.1 1017 Flash / max effort (owner-provided, runtime/upstream unverified). Your owner-selected advertised families are MiniMax and GLM, with no advertised overlap; upstream identity is unverified. Report only identity/settings directly visible to you; requested CLI flags alone are not proof of effective execution. The coordinator will inspect exact-run receipts. Stop identity research after stating available evidence/limits; do not browse global configs or other sessions. Do not confuse old planning xhigh effort with this final wave's explicit max.

# Required final report (no file writes)
EFFECTIVE_MODEL: requested identity/settings; configured identity/settings actually visible; runtime/modes/evidence; upstream verified or unverified. State limits honestly.
VERDICT: pass | changes_required | unverified.
BLOCKERS: numbered, with severity, file:line, actual vs expected behavior, contract citation, concrete evidence/reproduction or discriminating test gap, and the smallest correction needed. If none, say none.
SUGGESTIONS: clearly non-blocking items, or none.
FILES_AT_RISK: affected files/consumers, or none.
CONCEDED: prior concerns ruled out by evidence, limitations or omitted verification, or none.
Do not include patches, edit files, claim acceptance or start another review. Return a concise but complete evidence-backed report.

# Your selected runtime and primary lens
Owner request: GLM 5.3, max effort, through Qoder. The installed catalog exposes GLM-5.3; this run explicitly requests --model GLM-5.3 --reasoning-effort max with the built-in Plan agent. Primary lens: complete U5/spec/CLI parity, canonical vs declared skill identity, Diff summary/copy/file/hunk/truncation/binary/literal fidelity, canonical JSON mapping and stream equality, long-metadata/narrow-layout keyboard reachability, read-only captured-input boundaries, and scope/test/documentation accuracy. Also inspect the whole frozen scope for concrete blockers.
