Coordinator inspection reproduced these defects; correct within the SAME SIX allowed files and external scratch directory, all other bounds and both freezes unchanged. Original brief follows below.
1. Installed herdr --skill requires names match [a-z][a-z0-9_-]{0,31}. Current critic_qwen_HERDR-CRITIC-QWEN-<timestamp> / DeepSeek names contain uppercase and exceed32: invalid. Generate unique lowercase short token (e.g. uuid hex12 via existing Python) per critic; verify name regex and uniqueness, use variables consistently. Exact template semantics preserved.
2. date+%s and mkdir -p permit reuse. Require nonexisting dispatch root created EXCLUSIVELY (mkdir WITHOUT -p or tempfile.mkdtemp inside owned artifact root), empty fresh sessions subdir, fail on collision; do not delete/reuse old dirs. Retain actual process AND session IDs, ready distinct foreground shell panes, successful start/readiness before prompting. Distinguish template from observed independence.
3. TARGET currently only path. Include exact SHA256 (and revision if applicable) in the report TARGET envelope and complete brief; require exact token+target-path+hash match. Define PROMPT_QWEN/PROMPT_DEEPSEEK as complete independent supplied briefs before submission. Record separate prompt results including each exit code, not only logs; both launched before waits. Native waits not turn identity, inspect existing blocked/working state before sends, don't duplicate on uncertainty.
4. P03 must pass unique implementer token+target, complete constraints/report incl no delegation/review/commit, verify independently and hand revised fixture to FRESH critics with NEW tokens/empty dirs/processes. P02 pre-edit round does not prove post-implementation review. Preserve fingerprint-original-repo before/after as well as fixture; no writes to repo.
5. Restore ALL original pilot requirements in usable handoff: P01 fresh-context/integration proof; P04 deliberately long response and completeness validation (e.g. numbered payload/end marker, capture match token+hash), increase supported --lines if truncated, Pi capture-only or stop; other kinds fallback only if permitted. P05 observe actual blocked question UI and inspect/respond only authorized narrow reads, UNKNOWN/wider dialog stops, plus harmless denied-write probe and unchanged fingerprint, refusal alone not universal enforcement. P06 deliberate false-settle AND fast/stalled/uncertain reconciliation. P07 representative owned active/background command, explicit bounded PID/job evidence after interrupt, unresolved-liveness synthetic rejection until resolved; no uncontrolled orphan. P09 actual cmux wrapper interaction/cleanup proof; --version alone insufficient. Native runtime fields N/A and native controls recorded, upstream identities unverified.
6. P08 current 'restart via herdr --session...' is attach/start, not proof of restart. Human detach vs human controlled owned-session stop/relaunch are SEPARATE exercises. Read installed help for session stop/attach before documenting. Only external HUMAN may stop exact owned pilot after saved evidence/owned stop checks; no agent outside-Herdr controls, no stopping shared server, keep continuing coordinator and dirty/user resources safe, then fresh human Hermes startup/brief and verify context, no restored-layout inference. If exact detach UI shortcut unverified, instruct human use documented UI and retain actual action rather than invent.
7. Keep direct HUMAN Hermes startup as sole executable coordinator launch; setup currently presents herdr agent start coord as approved mapping without former separate-control-pane caveat. Replace that row's command with actual approved direct startup or explicitly NONEXECUTABLE historical alternate.
8. preflight-receipt.json still retains OLD checkoutHead/dispatch/baseline as root evidence while updating current mappings. Preserve clearly labeled historical provenance and append current mappingApplication record with current HEAD, BOTH freezes and worker task ref / configured route vs upstream unverified; do not imply all metadata observed by old dispatch. Restore unrelated acceptance.md historical execution receipt link (native-critic-amendment-execution-receipt.json exists); do not rewrite old historical report/link needlessly. Current application review pending; don't imply approved/checkpoint accepted/complete until coordinator.
9. Fix misleading route label anymodel/qwen3.8-max to native provider=anymodel/model=qwen/qwen3.8-max. Update own report to truthfully describe actual completeness/static checks and changes. Scope fingerprints show only your six permitted files changed. Remove trailing whitespace in edited docs where practical (git diff --check). Do NOT add tests/framework, run live pilot, change mappings/permissions or claim success.
Return full implementer schema; no narrative outside needed report. Coordinator will inspect, final source gates, both independent reviews.
ORIGINAL BRIEF:
Implement only the native-mapping documentation application checkpoint for Skill Lens. You are sole implementer Antigravity/Gemini 3.8 Flash High. Do not review, delegate, commit, push, or operate live Herdr.
Repository /Users/corvette/Documents/Projects Coding/Skill Lens, main HEAD 0c9991439309b1ce819abc4eb007664b872cc45b. Read AGENTS.md, docs/process/implementation-loop.md and relevant council rules.
Operative base docs/plans/2026-10-17-two-surface-orchestration.md @ 58d48cea483804b22767b381c6edd8274fe6ad44.
Operative amendment docs/plans/2026-10-17-herdr-native-pilot-critic-amendment.md @ b99e212a55b20757eeda8605db4edcc59aad6107. Verify freezes and that current amendment operative sections 1-7 equal reviewed draft implementation/native-critic-amendment-reviewed-draft.txt; current Reference differs only for provenance.
User explicitly approved exact amendment adoption/freeze and exact pair despite upstream identity/family unverified; setup approval already covers session skill-lens, pilot skill-lens-pilot-20261017, human-operated direct Hermes startup/restart, existing Hermes/Gemini/DeepSeek settings. Do not ask for them again.
Allowed edits ONLY below docs/validation/two-surface-orchestration/2026-10-17/:
setup.md
pilot.md
acceptance.md
implementation/preflight-receipt.json
implementation/human-pilot-brief.md
NEW implementation/native-mapping-application-report.md
External scratch/logs ONLY /tmp/skill-lens-herdr-native-mapping-implementation-20261017/.
Preserve .path, all historical reports, frozen plans, active process docs, product/tests/config/registry and all other paths. Baseline evidence already retained under implementation/native-mapping-application-baseline/; do not modify it.
Apply amendment exact Qwen/Pi AnyModel high and DeepSeek/Pi WorkBuddy high templates consistently, INCLUDING newly empty distinct per-dispatch session directories, different generated names/tokens, distinct actual available shell panes and independent processes/session IDs, no resume/continue.
Resolve CURRENT stale missing-critic1 mapping / setup-approval-pending gates in executable handoff while preserving historical truth. Record BOTH operative references and approval. ALL P01-P09 stay pending/unverified. No runtime success or completed pilot claim. No Phase C.
Revise human-pilot-brief.md into a usable complete copy/paste coordinator brief with approved human startup, genuine HERDR_ENV gate, explicit read herdr --skill (Hermes --ignore-rules suppresses context), exact two launch templates from amendment with runtime substitution, ready shell-pane IDs parsed from actual JSON, exact critic guard from council baseline, required critic schema + per-dispatch token/target envelope, complete independent prompts and target fingerprints. Both native prompt submission jobs must start BEFORE parent completion collection; retain separate submission results, native prompt --wait is not turn identity. Bind reports by token+target; reconcile uncertainty without duplicate sends.
P04 is complete native response capture OR capability unavailable/stop for these read-only Pi critics: they CANNOT write fallback files; coordinator may retain recovered text externally. Do not grant write/shell tools to rescue capture. Include full P01-P09 requirements, false settle/stalled/fast cases, deliberate stale-token rejection and unresolved-liveness rejection, bounded owned stop/process evidence, human detach/restart, cmux absolute CLI, protected user/coordinator/dirty-worktree cleanup. Do not invent syntax: inspect installed help for NEW command examples. No live control from outside Herdr, fake env, neighboring sessions, provider substitution, global config/routes/plugins/credentials/services/app changes.
Original repo remains read-only during pilot. Synthetic checkout /tmp/skill-lens-herdr-execution-20261017-cg7iv351/synthetic-checkout has fixture.txt initial SHA256 462b045a567486e8acd32f21f3861cb101a4b9c6ccbbb18613615c2ec707014e, content "pilot status: pending\n". Allow Gemini tiny synthetic edit only there; pilot outputs /tmp/skill-lens-herdr-execution-20261017-cg7iv351/pilot-artifacts. Fixture command HOME/XDG isolated with command-local env only; do not replace parent agent HOME/auth.
Source baseline freshly passed 1048 tests,1 expected filesystem skip,91.11% coverage,mypy37,Ruff clean/format215. Logs retained; coordinator will run final four gates after inspection, no need to duplicate full baseline. Do necessary static checks (JSON,links,exact mappings/guard,scope) outside repo and report truthful outcomes. Any required missing setup fact: report blocker rather than invent.
Return exactly council implementer fields EFFECTIVE_MODEL, OUTCOME, FILES_CHANGED, CHECKS, TESTS_ADDED, DEVIATIONS_FROM_PLAN, BLOCKED_ON. EFFECTIVE_MODEL describes YOUR Gemini requested/configured/runtime/interaction settings, with upstream identity unverified when no proof; not candidate Qwen identity. Report which checks you actually ran vs inherited baseline. Sol owns verification/review/commit.
