REQUEST_TOKEN: sol-mini-trial-plan-r3-gemini-20261023
  EFFECTIVE_MODEL: requested: Gemini 3.8 Flash (High) / configured:
  Gemini 3.8 Flash (High) / settings/mode: Model Selection set to
  Gemini 3.8 Flash (High), Plan Mode (/plan), read-only targeted
  round-3 critic / evidence: native read_file inspection only, zero
  shell/terminal commands, zero writes, zero background tasks, zero
  delegates / upstream identity unverified beyond platform API
  disclosure
  VERDICT: pass
  BLOCKERS: None.
  SUGGESTIONS: None required.
  FILES_AT_RISK: None. Review was conducted strictly read-only.
  Trial execution remains strictly isolated to disposable
  /tmp/skill-lens-herdr-mini-live-20261023-* and authorized
  documentation/receipt files, leaving user repository files,
  installed binaries, and running services untouched.
  CONCEDED:

  • Verified resolution of Offset residual (Prior blocker 1):
  Corrected Step 4 derives offset = native_clock - coordinator_clock
  within a ≤ 250 ms bracket half-width and |offset| ≤ 2 s, and
  converts native completion to coordinator time via completed_c =
  native_completed - offset. Corrected Step 8 and the acceptance
  table consistently enforce wait_return >= completed_c +
  timing_band, routing timing within the band, offset drift,
  excessive offset (> 2 s), or wall-clock steps to inconclusive or
  setup blockers without contradiction.
  • Verified resolution of Evidence-freeze blocker: Section 65, Step
  75, and the review decisions mandate freezing an immutable
  evidence package with a canonical manifest SHA-256 that both
  final-critic briefs and reports must explicitly name. Any evidence
  modification forces a new manifest and a complete re-review by
  both critics. Furthermore, each critic's own native completion and
  absence of active work are required, closing the full-TUI early-
  return vulnerability.
  • Ancillary edits verified: The additions of agent prompt and --
  until working to the syntax checks, citation of models --help,
  creation of the native session prior to Mini launch, removal of
  duplicate backend startup phrasing, and explicit allowance for
  targeted follow-ups are coherent and introduce no regressions.
  • Acknowledged material limits: Disposable single-turn scope,
  full-TUI defect separation (design-only), unverified upstream
  model weights beyond platform disclosure, and credential-free
  preflight halting remain accepted.
  COMPLETION: complete / no delegates / no background work
