REQUEST_TOKEN: sol-mini-trial-plan-r2-gemini-20261023
  EFFECTIVE_MODEL: requested: Gemini 3.8 Flash (High) / configured:
  Gemini 3.8 Flash (High) / settings/mode: Model Selection set to
  Gemini 3.8 Flash (High), Plan Mode (/plan), read-only targeted
  round-2 critic / evidence: native read_file inspection only, zero
  shell/terminal commands, zero writes, zero background tasks, zero
  delegates / upstream identity unverified beyond platform API
  disclosure
  VERDICT: pass
  BLOCKERS: None.
  SUGGESTIONS: None required.
  FILES_AT_RISK: None. Review was conducted strictly read-only.
  Trial execution remains strictly isolated to disposable
  /tmp/skill-lens-herdr-mini-live-20261023-* and authorized
  documentation/receipt files, leaving user repository files,
  installed binaries, and running services untouched.
  CONCEDED:

  • Prior blockers 1–6 resolved:
      1. Timing resolution/offset: Corrected step 4 establishes
      native units/resolution, enforces a two-second clock-offset
      ceiling, and defines timing_band; step 8 and acceptance
      require wait-return at least timing_band after native
      completion, treating inside-band returns as inconclusive.
      2. Wait status: Corrected step 7 and acceptance require a zero
      exit code and settled idle/done status, explicitly rejecting
      blocked, agent_prompt_stalled, timeout, or unknown.
      3. Exactly-one delivery: Corrected steps 3 and 7 enforce pre-
      prompt zero counts and post-prompt verification of exactly one
      token-bearing user message and one matching assistant turn.
      4. Concurrency: Corrected step 5 explicitly supervises the
      background prompt-wait process (recording PID, streams, status,
      and UTC/monotonic timestamps), while step 6 mandates that the
      observation probe execute before the wait process returns.
      5. Preflight order: Scope steps 1–9 are strictly chronological;
      step 2's credential-free model preflight strictly precedes
      toolchain download, build, Herdr startup, and Mini execution.
      6. Final acceptance: Acceptance criteria and the tri-state
      table require substantive pass from both fresh final critics
      on the same frozen evidence, with any non-pass triggering
      escalation.
  • Acknowledged material limits:
      • Single disposable generation: The trial validates the
      delivered screen-rule fix during a single live turn in a
      synthetic root; it does not constitute general Herdr
      reliability verification or formal smoke acceptance.
      • Full-TUI separation: The distinct integration-authority
      early-completion defect in full-TUI mode remains unresolved
      and strictly design-only.
      • Upstream model provenance: Upstream served model weights and
      family identity remain independently unverified beyond
      provider disclosure.
      • Passive regex detection bounds: Passive screen scraping
      cannot distinguish a literal unadorned bottom-line status
      string from an active footer.
      • Credential independence: If the model/variant is unavailable
      in the isolated credential-free profile during preflight,
      execution stops and returns to the owner.
      COMPLETION: complete / no delegates / no background work
