REQUEST_TOKEN: sol-mini-trial-plan-r2-gemini-20261023

You are the same independent planning critic, now doing a **targeted round 2** on the corrected draft. You previously reviewed draft SHA-256 af7d0eed50db41e96b3c1937350d5ec748d324f1bd73a83dde0b13ecc90b064d. The coordinator accepted and corrected the six blockers below. Judge whether each is genuinely resolved and whether the corrections introduced a new blocker. Do not reopen settled scope or demand a second live trial, installation, full-TUI trace, formal smoke, credential copying, or impossible certainty.

# Your one question

Are the six prior blockers genuinely resolved without weakening isolation, rollback or preservation, and did the corrections introduce a new safety blocker?

# Subject

Corrected plan: /Users/corvette/Documents/Projects Coding/Skill Lens/docs/plans/2026-10-23-herdr-mini-isolated-trial.md
Expected SHA-256: 5a592255d41c7dd3fd4b59860d4812c03c665a93c7c462ae1907c81441fd2abe
Status: Draft (round 2). Read the complete corrected plan. The coordinator will verify the file before/after your review; do not treat your review as a write check.

Prior review evidence (read-only):
- Your round-1 brief: /var/folders/tf/jsdyxcts6y72fs98s7wl3dfm0000gn/T/skill-lens-herdr-mini-trial-review-20261023-juh_i8ce/gemini-brief.txt
- Your round-1 report: /var/folders/tf/jsdyxcts6y72fs98s7wl3dfm0000gn/T/skill-lens-herdr-mini-trial-review-20261023-juh_i8ce/gemini-report.txt
- Named repository evidence from the round-1 brief remains the same; do not search incidents/recovered receipt files or unrelated user data.

# Prior blockers and corrections to verify

1. Timing resolution/offset: corrected execution step 4 now establishes unit, resolution and a two-second offset limit; step 8 and acceptance require wait-return at least `timing_band` after native completion, with inside-band as inconclusive.
2. Wait status: execution step 7 and acceptance now require zero exit and settled `idle`/`done`, rejecting `blocked`, `agent_prompt_stalled`, `timeout`, `unknown` or another error.
3. Exactly-one delivery: execution steps 3 and 7 now require pre-prompt zero user/assistant messages and post-prompt exactly one token-bearing user message, one matching assistant and no other turns.
4. Concurrency: execution step 5 now specifies a supervised background prompt-wait process with PID/streams/exit/status and UTC+monotonic times; step 6 requires the single observer before that wait returns or the run is inconclusive.
5. Preflight order: scope steps are chronological; step 2's credential-free model preflight strictly precedes tool download/build (steps 3–5), Herdr startup (step 6) and Mini setup (step 9).
6. Final acceptance: both fresh final critics must return substantive `pass` on the same frozen evidence; one `changes_required`/`unverified` blocks acceptance and escalates.

Also verify the accepted suggestions: tri-state pass/failure/inconclusive table; live evidence-command syntax check; substantive answer rather than markers alone; plan-only then reference-only commit wording; fresh token ledger; clock/onboarding checks.

# Current facts

- Corrected draft hash above; no build/server/prompt has run.
- Round 1: Gemini pass, OpenCode changes_required. Pre/post checkout, HEAD, 1,305 file fingerprints, plan hash and the three original user files were unchanged.
- The OpenCode round-1 critic used a broad read that surfaced a preserved receipt file outside named evidence; it reports no content used/quoted, no credentials/raw transcripts read, no writes. Do not repeat that search.

# Controls

- Native file read/search tools ONLY. Do NOT run shell/terminal commands, scripts, builds, tests, linters, formatters, git, network, archive extraction or delegates, even in /tmp. Sol owns all runtime verification and fingerprints.
- Do NOT read or copy credentials, auth files, raw agent transcripts, old session exports, incidents folders or recovered-coordinator-receipts.
- Use only the corrected plan, the prior brief/report named above, and the named repository evidence. Do not search unrelated user data.
- One complete report only. Do not write a report file. Stop after the report.

READ-ONLY CRITIC TASK. You are reviewing, not implementing.

Do NOT create, edit, move, delete or rename any file in the repository. Do NOT run
any command that writes: no formatters, no linters with --fix, no install, no
git commit/checkout/stash, no snapshot or golden regeneration, no test runs that
write into the checkout. Test output, if you need it, goes only to a temporary
directory outside the repository.

If you believe a change is required, do not make it. Report it instead.

Return only the report format below. Nothing else.


# Report format

REQUEST_TOKEN: <the token above>
EFFECTIVE_MODEL: requested / configured / settings/mode / evidence / upstream identity verified or unverified
VERDICT: pass | changes_required | unverified
BLOCKERS: for each unresolved prior blocker, state "prior blocker N unresolved" with exact corrected-plan location and evidence. Add any new blocker with exact location/impact/evidence. Say "None." if none.
SUGGESTIONS: non-blocking only, or "None required."
FILES_AT_RISK: files whose behavior or safety could be affected, or "None."
CONCEDED: material limits you accept as adequately disclosed, including which prior blockers you now consider resolved.
COMPLETION: complete / no delegates / no background work
