### EFFECTIVE_MODEL

  • Requested: Gemini 3.8 Flash (High)
  • Configured: Gemini 3.8 Flash (High)
  • Settings: Model Selection set to
  Gemini 3.8 Flash (High)
  • Mode: Plan Mode (/plan), read-only
  critic
  • Evidence: Session logs and environment
  verify execution under Gemini 3.8 Flash
  (High). Read-only inspections and
  isolated tests conducted strictly
  outside the repository in temporary
  directories; zero repository
  modifications, zero git modifications,
  zero delegates or background tasks.
  • Upstream limits: Upstream served model
  weights/family identity remain
  independently unverified beyond platform
  API disclosure.
  ──────
  ### VERDICT

  pass
  ──────
  ### BLOCKERS

  None
  ──────
  ### INDEPENDENT TARGETED RE-VERIFICATION
  & EVIDENCE ASSESSMENT

  1. Rejection of Bullets, Box-Drawing,
  and No-Space Suffixes; Acceptance of
  Real Block Frames:
      • Leading Glyphs Restricted to
      Legacy Computing Blocks: The rule
      uses ^(?:[\x{1CD00}-
      \x{1CEBF}\x{1FB00}-\x{1FBFF}]\s+
      )?esc stop · .... Real OpenCode
      block-spinner frames (🯦 U+1FBE6, 🯧
      U+1FBE7, 🯨 U+1FBE8) fall in
      \x{1FB00}-\x{1FBFF} and match
      cleanly. Undecorated footers (esc
      stop · ...) also match via the
      optional group.
      • Bullets & Box-Drawing Rejected:
      Triangular bullet (▸ U+25B8), round
      bullet (● U+25CF), arrow pointer (►
      U+25BA), and box-drawing vertical
      bar (│ U+2502) lie outside the
      Legacy Computing code-point ranges.
      Because no leading whitespace or
      unlisted punctuation is permitted
      before esc stop, lines prefixed with
      these glyphs fail anchor matching
      and evaluate to Idle.
      • No-Space Suffixes Rejected: The
      terminal provider token is strictly
      constrained to identifier
      characters: [\w.\-]+$. No-space
      trailing suffixes such as brackets
      ([copied]), parentheses ((copied)),
      or punctuation/guillemets (» U+00BB)
      cannot be absorbed by the provider
      token and fail to match the terminal
      anchor $, correctly evaluating to
      Idle.
  2. Priority Resolution
  (permission_required 300 vs
  status_footer_esc_stop_working 105):
      • In approval-over-busy (△
      Permission required\n{busy}), both
      permission_required (priority 300,
      whole_recent) and
      status_footer_esc_stop_working
      (priority 105,
      bottom_non_empty_lines(1)) match.
      Priority 300 wins, yielding state
      Blocked.
      • In priority-mutation.json,
      mutating rule 105 to priority 350
      under the current matcher flipped
      the observed state to Working with
      guard_detects_regression: true,
      verifying that the priority boundary
      is active, tested, and load-bearing.
  3. Internal Evidence Consistency:
      • Matcher Alignment: The exact
      pattern line_regex =
      ['''^(?:[\x{1CD00}-
      \x{1CEBF}\x{1FB00}-\x{1FBFF}]\s+
      )?esc stop · [^·/\n"'“”‘’]+ ·
      [^·/\n"'“”‘’]+ · [^·/\n"'“”‘’]+ /
      [\w.-]+$''']` is identical across
      opencode.toml:22,
      distribution opencode.toml,
      priority-mutation.json:4,
      provenance.json:70, and
      verification.json:83.
      • Matrix & Quality: cli-results.json
      records all 29 cases with ok: true,
      matched rule IDs, and origin
      descriptions. verification.json and
      source-quality.txt record 100 passed
      detector tests, clean Clippy
      (warnings denied), and clean cargo
      fmt --check, explicitly noting that
      the earlier 13-case matrix and
      exact-glyph matchers are superseded.
      • Patch & Hashes: correction.patch
      matches SHA-256
      2567a9fee5b36f0fa6f3cf92f40cc33c9a73
      473dfa90d2184ab68948fd0469b0. Clean
      application to pristine files
      extracted from herdr-v0.9.5.tar.gz
      reproduces the exact SHA-256 hashes
      for all 4 files matching baseline.
      json, patch-reconstruction.json, and
      final-review-checkout-r5:
          • src/detect/manifests/opencode.
          toml:
          95a282e0376b2cc1f21600fae79b52ec
          04e6927aab985fd24c5e9ba2e75e838f
          • distribution/agent-
          detection/opencode.toml:
          95a282e0376b2cc1f21600fae79b52ec
          04e6927aab985fd24c5e9ba2e75e838f
          • src/detect/manifest/tests.rs:
          f9914be529ba9d7a4280954054f0a473
          5e8b5b8713e1db0a5f6550505e9f6937
          •
          docs/next/website/src/content/do
          cs/agents.mdx:
          3114e638f419fc1438a2a9c2c25faa0d
          a3bc6a156d4a91c1d91e81bbe7383e68

  4. Honesty of Disclosed mini.mono
  Limitation:
      • agents.mdx:180 explicitly states:
      "The rule recognizes the default
      block-spinner frames; if the Mini
      footer uses an ASCII spinner instead,
      it is not treated as working and the
      pane reads idle, which is the pre-
      existing behavior for that
      configuration."
      • It also preserves honest
      disclaimers that a byte-identical
      bottom row cannot be distinguished
      from a running footer, that screen-
      shape rules do not change agent wait
      lifecycle semantics, and that the
      separate full-TUI premature-
      completion issue remains unresolved.
      No claims are overstated.

  ──────
  ### SUGGESTIONS

  • Upstream PR Documentation: Retain the
  explicit disclosure in PR documentation
  that OpenCode ASCII-spinner
  configurations (mini.mono) continue to
  report idle as before. Should upstream
  OpenCode change its default spinner away
  from Legacy Computing blocks, or should
  Herdr adopt a semantic IPC/OSC escape
  sequence, detection can transition from
  line-oriented regex scraping to
  protocol-level status.
  ──────
  ### FILES_AT_RISK

  None

  • Zero files created, modified, moved,
  or deleted in the repository checkout.
  • All upstream changes remain strictly
  isolated to the four authorized paths in
  the /tmp/skill-lens-herdr-mini-20261022-
  o1x7n059 scratch tree.
  ──────
  ### CONCEDED

  • A literal, unadorned status footer
  printed as the terminal's bottom-most
  non-empty line remains indistinguishable
  from an active footer under passive
  screen-shape regex scraping.
  • ASCII/mono spinner frames are
  intentionally excluded, falling back to
  idle.
  • Verification is strictly offline; no
  live OpenCode Mini session, installed
  Herdr binary modification, or service
  restart was performed.
  • The separate full-TUI premature-
  completion defect remains unresolved by
  design.
  ──────
  ### COMPLETION

  complete/no delegates/background work`
