EFFECTIVE_MODEL: [ opencode/muse-spark-1.3-contributor-free, round-two focused follow-up read-only critic, Plan mode no writes/no delegation | evidence: requested=focused round-two reviewer per brief vs configured=T3 catalog runtime vs confirmed=plan-mode restraint observed (reads only, no edits, no checkout mutation) | unverified: upstream served model/family/effort under owner-selected named pair ]
VERDICT: pass
BLOCKERS: [ none ]
SUGGESTIONS: [ endpoint overlap adds no version diversity today (min 8.2.8 / latest 8.2.8, installed-receipt.json endpoint_overlap.overlap=true with honest note) — retain disclosure, no arbitrary cap per frozen scope; adapter proves existence/callability/notification/first-fault/code shape, not future Textual semantic drift (e.g. ignored _return_code or auto-cleared _exception would still pass shape check) — current loud-failure is correct R02 mitigation, behavior-drift test is future work; coordinator evidence is macOS/Python 3.11 only with no Linux/CI/full-matrix claim — keep that disclosure, CI matrix exists but unexecuted lanes not claimed; all_packaged_source_bytes_match is coordinator-side field not harness-produced — archive completeness genuinely proved and build.log confirms wheel built from sdist so installs transitively cover sdist, but byte-equality is one-off not re-runnable; CI cold-cache/timeout and _clean_env PATH inheritance remain bounded risks — lane pytest ~37s vs 180s cap, base install 60s cap tightest, parent PATH inherited under uv run but all lane binaries absolute and fresh-install succeeded; new test_verify_base_install_fails_when_textual_is_present assumes Textual present in unit-test env (uses _REAL_SUBPROCESS_RUN with sys.executable, like test_installed_extra_output_parity does) — correct in dev env, would not fail-closed in a Textual-free dev env; hygiene optional only: test_stage_g_repairs docstring floor/latest wording, REQUIRED_REGISTRY_COUNT exact-equality, --verify-tui-only unused by CI, copytree carries tests/__pycache__ into lane ]
FILES_AT_RISK: [ scripts/smoke_wheel.py (the four now-guarded lane checks plus cache/timeout/PATH handling), tests/test_tui_packaging.py (corrected _make_packaging_subprocess_runner double and five new guard tests — the only file in correction-only.diff), .github/workflows/ci.yml (cold-cache packaging job, no macOS-local evidence beyond coordinator lanes), skill_lens/tui/_textual_compat.py (private Textual coupling, textual>=8.2.8 open-ended), skill_lens/tui/__init__.py + app.py (unchanged since first council, fingerprint-verified) ]
CONCEDED: [ suspected project-isolation break — withdrawn: all five new tests use tmp_path invoking_cwd + monkeypatch.chdir + mock_home where HOME/sandbox needed, monkeypatch.setattr reverted automatically, hostile leak is (Path(dst).parent/"skill_lens").mkdir under tmp_path work_dir only; suspected installed-validity invalidation by test-only change — withdrawn: correction-only.diff touches only tests/test_tui_packaging.py, source_hash a28bc7f8... matches before-review-fingerprints.json, wheel 59707ca7... sdist 273ef44... unchanged, installed-run.json all_packaged_source_bytes_match:true + sdist_current_test_harness_bytes_match:true, build.log wheel-from-sdist, base textual_absent:true, min/latest each 353 passed/0 skipped outside checkout with provenance inside venv and source_unshadowed:true; suspected source masking via mocked subprocess.run — withdrawn: mocks return controlled provenance/returncode but production does real string-containment/returncode/assert-exists checks on real tmp_path filesystem; hostile copytree exercises real assert not (test_lane/"skill_lens").exists(); textual test executes actual generated check_textual_cmd via _REAL_SUBPROCESS_RUN; suspected unrelated-failure kills — withdrawn: all six new mutants show clean 0 / mutant 1 / restored 0 with DID NOT RAISE behavioral failures in the targeted test only (base_origin 1 failed, endpoint_pkg [True-False] 1 failed/2 passed, endpoint_tui [False-True] 1 failed/2 passed, textual DID NOT RAISE CalledProcessError, installed-suite DID NOT RAISE AssertionError code 1, source-copy DID NOT RAISE AssertionError), no syntax/import errors; suspected incomplete branch coverage for OR guard — withdrawn: parametrize (True,False)/(False,True)/(True,True) plus split mutants endpoint_pkg_origin_ignored (drops pkg branch) and endpoint_tui_origin_ignored (drops tui branch) each kill exactly one single-outside case ]
